“Ashley,” Randy Coleman shouted. “Tell these cops to get these cuffs off of me. I just saved your life.”

The other man said nothing. He just stared at Ashley. She stared back until it dawned on her that she knew him. Then she looked away quickly and took a step back.

Rain cascaded off his shaved head and ran down the length of his thick, jet-black beard. His eye color was different, too. Probably contacts. But there was no doubt that the police had captured Joshua Maxfield.

Larry Birch brought Ashley to Ann Rostow’s office where she was given a mug of hot tea and a towel to dry her hair.

“Tell me what happened in the lot,” Larry Birch said when she was ready to discuss the attack.

“I was bending down to unlock my door when I saw someone’s reflection in the window.”

“Maxfield?”

“I can’t tell you. The rainclouds blocked most of the sunlight. You know how heavy the rain is. And the window was streaked with water. It distorted everything. And he was wearing a hood.”

“So you can’t say if Maxfield or Coleman assaulted you?”

Ashley stared at the detective. She saw that his question was serious.

“It had to be Maxfield,” Ashley said. “You don’t think Coleman attacked me?”

“I have to keep an open mind.”

“What does he say?”

“Coleman is screaming bloody murder. He’s taking credit for saving your life and capturing Maxfield. He says that he came to visit his wife and just happened to be in the right place at the right time.”

“That makes sense.”

“Our problem is that his car pulled into the lot after you parked, but he never went inside the nursing home.”

“What does he say about that?”

“He says that he hasn’t seen Ms. Van Meter since she went into the coma and he felt that he should find out about her condition firsthand.”

“I bet his lawyer told him to go so he’d look good in court.”

Birch shrugged. “I don’t know anything about that.”

“Why didn’t he go in?”

“He claims he had a change of heart after he parked, because he wasn’t sure he could handle seeing Ms. Van Meter so helpless. According to Coleman, he was working out his feelings when he saw you leave. He says that he was coming over to talk to you when Maxfield attacked and he came to the rescue.”

“Is that what your surveillance team saw?”

“Unfortunately, we didn’t have a clear view. You were between the cars and the attacker came from the middle of the lot. We didn’t even see that you were in trouble until you ran. Then someone rushed out from between two cars, but our view was obstructed by the other cars and our angle, and they were dressed similarly.”

“Is Maxfield saying he rescued me from Coleman?”

“Maxfield isn’t talking.”

“He’s tried to kill me before.”

“Yeah, he has. And I suspect that we’ll be charging him with another attempt.”

The door opened and an officer stuck his head in. “There’s a Jerry Philips out here. He says he’s Miss Spencer’s attorney and that you called him.”

“Let him in,” Birch said.

Jerry went to Ashley as soon as he walked in the door.

“Are you okay?”

Ashley nodded.

“What happened?” Philips asked Ashley and the detective.

“Joshua Maxfield tried to kill me,” Ashley answered.

“He’s in custody,” Birch added.

“Thank God,” Philips said.

“Randy Coleman saved me.”

“Coleman? What was he doing here?”

“He says that he was going to visit his wife when he saw Maxfield try to kill Miss Spencer,” Birch said. “She was running for help when Coleman tackled him.”

“Are you hurt?”

“No, I’m fine.”

“She didn’t panic,” Birch said. “She fought him off. She was very brave.”

Jerry turned to Ashley. “You must have been scared to death.”

“I was, but I’m better now.”

Jerry looked at Birch. “Are you finished? Can I take Ashley home?”

“Yeah. I’ll need a statement but we can do that tomorrow. Can you drive Miss Spencer? We have to go over her car for evidence and we can’t turn it back to her today.”

“That’s fine. It’s a rental. You can give it back to the agency when you’re through.”

“This is great,” Jerry said as soon as they were underway. “Maxfield is going to prison. You don’t have to be afraid of him anymore.”

“They arrested him before and he escaped,” Ashley said.

“That won’t happen this time. He’ll be watched like a hawk.”

Ashley didn’t reply. She shut her eyes and laid her head against the back of the seat. Jerry must have thought that she was asleep, because he didn’t speak for the rest of the trip.

“We’re here,” he said as soon as he parked in front of her building.

Ashley got out of the car without saying a word. Jerry followed her inside. There was a clock in the living room. The time shocked her. It was only a little after one in the afternoon. Ashley felt as if she’d been up for days.

“Are you hungry?” Jerry asked. “Do you want me to fix something for you?”

“Okay?”

“Let me rummage around in the fridge.”

Ashley slumped down at the kitchen table.

“Feel like telling me what’s bothering you?” Jerry asked while he made them ham-and-cheese sandwiches.

“Do you think it’s possible that it was Randy Coleman who attacked me?”

The question took Philips by surprise. “I thought he saved you.”

“He probably did. But the attack seemed-I don’t know-clumsy. I saw Maxfield in action once. It was at the pool at the Academy. Coleman was bothering the dean and he got violent. Maxfield was there. He handled Coleman very easily. It was like in the movies, almost choreographed it was so smooth, bang, bang, and it was over. Maxfield didn’t break a sweat.”

Ashley lost color for a moment. She looked down and swallowed.

“What is it?” Jerry asked, concerned.

“I was remembering when…when I was attacked. In my house. I was overpowered easily, too. Maxfield was so efficient. The man who attacked me in the lot…” She shook her head.

“You reacted quickly. You knocked him off balance. He probably wasn’t expecting that.”

“I guess.”

Jerry carried the sandwiches and two glasses of soda to the table and sat down.

“Do you have any reason to doubt that Joshua Maxfield murdered your parents and attacked you in the Academy dorm?”

Ashley thought before answering.

“I never saw his face in my house or in the dorm, but I definitely saw him in the boathouse. And he wrote that novel where the killer eats before he murders the teenage daughter. How could he possibly know that happened at my house?”

“So, there you are. If he tried to kill you several times before, why would he suddenly save your life today?”

Ashley was about to take a bite out of her sandwich when an idea occurred to her.

“Would Coleman benefit if I died?” she asked.

Jerry thought about that. “With you out of the picture there would be one less person trying to be appointed Casey’s guardian and conservator.”

“Miles would still be opposing him.”

“Yes, but he and Miles want the same thing, even if Randy claims otherwise.”

“What’s that?”

“They both want to take Casey off life support.”

“But Randy’s attorney said…”

“I know what he said but I don’t believe it. Casey doesn’t have a will and she has a large estate. If she dies intestate Coleman will get a lot of it because they’re still married. He may say he wants to keep her alive but I bet he’d change his tune in a minute if he’s appointed her guardian. You’re the only one who’s dedicated to keeping Casey alive.”

Ashley stared across the table at Jerry. She felt frightened.

“You just said that Coleman would get ‘a lot of’ Casey’s estate. Does that mean he doesn’t get it all, even though she doesn’t have a will?”

Jerry colored. “He wouldn’t be the only heir.”