Part Five.Sibling Rivalry
Chapter Thirty-Eight
An FBI agent drove Ashley from Murder for Fun to Sea-Tac airport, and an FBI jet flew her home. Delilah Wallace and Larry Birch had a car waiting at Portland International. When they were on the road, Delilah told Ashley that Randy Coleman had been picked up for questioning in connection with the attack at Sunny Rest. Ashley had trouble concentrating on the details of the arrest and only heard half of what the prosecutor said. She felt drained after her confrontation with Miles Van Meter, emotionally spent and physically exhausted. Ashley wished that she could curl up next to Jerry in their big comfortable bed and sleep the night away, but there was still one thing she had to do first.
A little before midnight, Larry Birch parked his unmarked car in front of the Van Meter mansion. Lights came on after the second ring. Moments later, a sleepy-eyed maid dressed in a nightgown and bathrobe opened the front door. Birch flashed his badge. The maid looked confused.
“We need to speak to Ms. Van Meter,” Birch said.
“She’s sleeping.”
“Who is it, Angela?” Casey called from the top of the stairs. She was wearing a blue silk robe over her nightgown. Delilah pushed past the maid and stood next to one of the suits of armor at the bottom of the stairs.
“It’s me, Delilah Wallace. Ashley is here, too.”
“What’s going on?” Casey asked. “It’s midnight.”
“I know, and I’m sorry to bother you, but something terrible has happened to Miles and we wanted to tell you in person. Is there someplace we can sit down and talk?”
“Please tell me what happened,” Casey said when they were seated in the library, where Delilah had met with Miles and Henry Van Meter many years earlier. Casey had taken the sofa, and Ashley sat beside her. Delilah and Larry Birch were opposite the couch in their own deep armchairs.
“Let me, Delilah,” Ashley said. “I should be the one to tell her. I’m her daughter. Miles is my uncle.”
“Tell me what?” Casey said, as she looked back and forth between Ashley and Delilah. Ashley turned sideways so she was facing Casey. They were inches apart.
“Miles has been arrested,” Ashley said. “Joshua Maxfield didn’t kill my father or Tanya Jones. It was Miles.”
Casey shook her head in disbelief. “That’s ridiculous.”
“I know this will be hard for you to believe,” Delilah said, “but your brother is a serial killer.”
Casey laughed. “I don’t know who told you that but…it’s insane. Miles isn’t a killer.”
“His vanity tripped him up,” Ashley said. “Remember the book that Joshua Maxfield wrote?”
Casey nodded.
“There was a draft in Maxfield’s cabin. It turns out that it was Miles who wrote it, not Joshua. If he could get it published, he could brag about his crimes without getting arrested, so he sent it to Maxfield for editing. But Joshua had writer’s block and he was desperate for a story idea. He rewrote Miles’s book. He plagiarized the draft.”
Casey was rigid, her hands clasped in her lap, her back straight. “I don’t believe any of this.”
Ashley leaned forward and laid a hand on Casey’s knee. “It’s true. They found Miles’s fingerprints all over the draft. They searched Miles’s house. There was a letter in the den from Joshua trying to discourage Miles from looking for a publisher.”
Ashley looked down. “They also found souvenirs that Miles took from his victims. They…Tanya Jones’s panties were…”
Ashley’s breath caught and she couldn’t go on. Casey’s mouth gaped open. She shook her head again.
“How could it be possible? I would have known.”
“Don’t beat yourself up about this, Casey,” Delilah said. “Miles had us all fooled.”
“But he’s my brother.” Casey breathed deeply as she fought to control her emotions.
“We do have one problem, though,” Larry Birch said. “We were hoping you could help clear it up.”
Casey turned toward the detective.
“We know that Joshua Maxfield didn’t kill Ashley’s father and Tanya Jones,” Delilah said. “And the only reason he would have had to kill Terri Spencer was to keep her from telling the police about his book, but he didn’t write the book, so he didn’t have a motive to kill Mrs. Spencer.”
“We also know that Miles was three thousand miles away when you and Terri were attacked in the boathouse,” Birch said. “We talked with the two attorneys from Brucher, Platt who were with him in New York. We are absolutely certain Miles could not have been in Oregon when Mrs. Spencer was killed.”
“So, that’s our problem,” Delilah said. “If Miles and Joshua Maxfield didn’t kill Mrs. Spencer, who did?”
Casey stiffened for a moment. Then she threw up her hands. “It had to be Joshua. He was standing there.”
“But you never actually saw him stab Terri Spencer, did you?” Delilah asked gently.
Casey hesitated. She shook her head slowly. She seemed confused.
“No, I didn’t. He was just there. I assumed… Oh, my God. I feel terrible.”
“Now that we know that Joshua Maxfield is innocent, we’ve arrested Randy Coleman for the attack on Ashley at Sunny Rest,” Delilah said. “Joshua testified that he saw a man who looked like Randy Coleman running from the boathouse. Do you think Coleman could have killed Terri Spencer? Maxfield thought he was after you and Terri was just in the wrong place at the wrong time. What do you think?”
Casey looked guilt-stricken. She wrung her hands.
“I’ve done something terrible,” she whispered.
“What have you done, Mom?” Ashley asked.
Being called “mom” seemed to unsettle Casey. “You have to understand, I was certain that Joshua killed Terri and Ashley’s father. I knew he’d attacked me. And Miles said…”
“Said what, Casey?” Delilah prodded.
Casey swallowed. She looked awful. “You know that I asked Dr. Linscott to let Miles visit after I came out of my coma? He was my first visitor.”
Delilah nodded.
“Miles told me what had happened while I was in the coma. He said that everyone knew Joshua killed Norman and that teenage girl at Ashley’s house. He said that Joshua tried to kill Ashley twice more after he failed at her house. He said Joshua had killed Terri. I told him about Randy but he said I must have been mistaken, that I had to say it was Joshua who murdered Terri.”
“What did you tell Miles about Randy Coleman?” Delilah asked.
Casey looked at Delilah. She seemed on the verge of tears. “I didn’t mean to lie. Miles told me that I had to say it was Joshua, or Joshua would be acquitted. But I did see Randy that evening. I saw him leaving the boathouse just before I went in.”
“You’re certain about that?” Larry Birch asked.
Casey nodded. “I know I should have said something, but he was my husband, and Miles…” She looked down again.
“So you saw Randy Coleman leaving the boathouse right before you walked in and found Terri Spencer’s body?” Delilah asked.
“Yes.”
“And he was your husband and you still had feelings for him, so you decided to cover for him?”
Casey nodded.
“Well that presents us with a whole ’nother problem,” Delilah said. “See, Joshua Maxfield says that he made up that story. He says he didn’t see anyone running from the boathouse after he heard those screams. There was nobody else there-except you.”
Casey’s eyes widened. Her head swung back and forth from Delilah to Birch and Ashley. They were all watching her carefully.
“One other thing, Ms. Van Meter,” the detective said. “After Miles was arrested we had a little chat. Know what he told us?”
Casey just stared at the detective.
“He told us that you killed Terri Spencer.”
“No, no. Miles would never turn on me,” Casey insisted.
Delilah smiled sadly. “You love your brother very much, don’t you?”