But Dolly had felt she had to. She had known Skip Reardon and liked him and just felt she had to try to help him. Besides, she really had seen that car, as had Michael, the five-year-old little boy with all the learning problems she had been minding that night. He had seen the car too, but Skip’s lawyer had told her not to discuss it.

“That would only hurt our case,” Mr. Farrell had said. “All we want you to do is to tell what you saw, that a dark sedan was parked in front of the Reardon house at nine and drove away a few minutes later.”

She was sure she had made out one of the numbers and one of the letters, a 3 and an L. But then the prosecutor had held up a license plate at the back of the courtroom and she hadn’t been able to read it. And he had gotten her to admit that she was very fond of Skip Reardon because he had dug out her car one night when she got stuck in a snowdrift.

Dolly knew that just because Skip had been nice to her didn’t mean that he couldn’t be a murderer, but in her heart she felt that he was innocent, and she prayed for him every night. Sometimes, even now, when she was baby-sitting across the street from the Reardon house, she would look out and think about the night Suzanne was murdered. And she would think about little Michael-his family had moved away several years ago-who would be fifteen now, and how he had pointed to the strange black car and said, “Poppa’s car.”

Dolly could not know that at the same time on that Sunday evening that she sat looking out the window at what used to be the Reardon house, some ten miles away, at Villa Cesare in Hillsdale, Geoff Dorso and Kerry McGrath were talking about her.

By tacit agreement, Kerry and Geoff refrained from any discussion of the Reardon case until coffee was served. During the earlier part of the meal, Geoff talked about spending his youngest years in New York. “I thought of my New Jersey cousins as living in the sticks,” he said. “Then after we moved out ourselves and I grew up here, I decided to stay.”

He told Kerry that he had four younger sisters.

“I envy you,” she said. “I’m an only child, and I used to love to visit my friends’ houses where there was a big family. I always thought it would be nice to have some siblings floating around. My father died when I was nineteen and my mother remarried when I was twenty-one and moved to Colorado. I see her twice a year.”

Geoff’s eyes softened. “That doesn’t give you much family support,” he said.

“No, I guess not, but Jonathan and Grace Hoover have helped to fill the gap. They’ve been wonderful to me, almost like parents.”

They talked about law school, agreeing that the first year was a horror they would hate to have to endure again. “What made you decide to be a defense lawyer?” Kerry asked.

“I think it went back to when I was a kid. A woman in our apartment building, Anna Owens, was one of the nicest people I ever knew. I remember when I was about eight and ran through the lobby to catch the elevator, I slammed into her and knocked her over. Anyone else would have had a screaming fit, but she just picked herself up and said, ‘Geoff, the elevator will come back, you know.’ Then she laughed. She could tell how upset I was.”

“That didn’t make you become a defense lawyer.” Kerry smiled.

“No. But three months later when her husband walked out on her, she followed him to his new girlfriend’s apartment and shot him. I honestly believe it was temporary insanity, which was the defense her lawyer tried, but she went to prison for twenty years anyway. I guess the key phrase is ‘mitigating circumstances.’ When I believe those are present, or when I believe the defendant is innocent, as with Skip Reardon, I take the case.” He paused. “And what made you become a prosecutor?”

“The victim and the family of the victim,” she said simply. “Based on your theory I could have shot Bob Kinellen and pled mitigating circumstances.”

Dorso’s eyes flashed with mild irritation, then became amused.

“Somehow I don’t see you shooting anybody, Kerry.”

“I don’t either, unless…” Kerry hesitated, then continued, “Unless Robin were in danger. Then I’d do whatever it took to save her. I’m sure of that.”

Over dinner, Kerry found herself talking about her father’s death. “I was in my sophomore year at Boston College. He had been a Pan Am captain and later went into the corporate end and was made an executive vice president. From the time I was three years old, he took my mother and me all over. To me, he was the greatest man in the world.” She gulped. “And then one weekend when I was home from college, he said he wasn’t feeling right. But he didn’t bother going to the doctor because he’d just had his annual physical. He said he’d be fine in the morning. But the next morning, he didn’t wake up.”

“And your mother remarried two years later?” Geoff asked softly.

“Yes, right before I graduated from college. Sam was a widower and a friend of Dad’s. He’d been about to retire to Vail when Dad died. He has a lovely place there. It’s been good for both of them.”

“What would your father have thought of Bob Kinellen?”

Kerry laughed. “You’re very perceptive, Geoff Dorso. I think he would have been underwhelmed.”

Over coffee they finally discussed the Reardon case. Kerry began by saying frankly, “I sat in on the sentencing ten years ago, and the look on his face and what he said were imprinted in my memory. I’ve heard a lot of guilty people swear they were innocent-after all, what have they got to lose?-but there was something about his statement that got to me.”

“Because he was telling the truth.”

Kerry looked directly at him. “I warn you, Geoff, I intend to play devil’s advocate, and while reading that transcript raises a lot of questions for me, it certainly doesn’t convince me that Reardon is an innocent man. Neither did yesterday’s visit. Either he’s lying or Dr. Smith is lying. Skip Reardon has a very good reason to lie. Smith doesn’t. I still think it’s damaging that the very day Suzanne died, Reardon had discussed divorce and apparently flipped when he learned what it might cost him.”

“Kerry, Skip Reardon was a self-made man. He pulled himself out of poverty and had become very successful. Suzanne had already cost him a fortune. You heard him. She was a big-time shopaholic, buying whatever struck her fancy.” He paused. “No. Being angry and being vocal about it is one thing. But there’s a hell of a difference between blowing off steam and murder. If anything, even though a divorce was going to be expensive, he was actually relieved that his sham marriage was going to be over, so he could get on with his life.”

They talked about the sweetheart roses. “I absolutely believe Skip neither brought nor sent them,” Geoff said as he sipped espresso. “So if we accept that, we then have the factor of another person.”

As Geoff was paying the bill, they both agreed that Dr. Smith’s testimony was the linchpin that had convicted Skip Reardon. “Ask yourself this,” Geoff urged. “Dr. Smith claimed that Suzanne was afraid of Skip and his jealous rages. But if she were so afraid of him, how could she stand there and calmly arrange flowers another man had sent her, and not only arrange them, but flaunt them, at least according to Skip. Does that make sense?”

“If Skip was telling the truth, but we don’t know that for an absolute fact, do we?” Kerry said.

“Well, I for one do believe him,” Geoff said with passion. “Besides, no one testified in corroboration of Dr. Smith’s testimony. The Reardons were a popular couple. Surely if he were abusive to her, someone would have come forward to say so.”

“Perhaps so,” Kerry conceded, “but then why were there no defense fact witnesses to say that he wasn’t insanely jealous? Why were there only two character witnesses called to help counter Dr. Smith’s testimony? No, Geoff, I’m afraid that based on the information the jury was given, they had no reason not to trust Dr. Smith and believe him. Besides, aren’t we in general conditioned to trust a physician?”