“Can I help you?” she asked, frowning.

“I… saw you upstairs. I…”

“I’m nothing to do with the auction.”

“No, but… haven’t we met? I mean, don’t we… know each other?”

“I don’t think so.”

“My name’s Tim Harding.”

The frown deepened. “I don’t know anyone by that name.”

“You’re Hayley Winter, right? The auction people told me.”

“Did they?”

“Yes,” he replied. Her voice, light and accentless, meant as little to Harding as her name. But he had looked into her wide, dark eyes before. He had no doubt of that. “I know this must seem odd, but, although you don’t recognize my name and I don’t recognize yours, we have met. Honestly. We know each other. Somehow.”

“I don’t think so.”

“Do you come from round here?”

“No. I moved down from London last year. What about you?”

“No. I… live abroad. I haven’t been to Penzance for… six or seven years.”

Hayley Winter’s frown was suddenly tinged with curiosity. “Which is it?” she asked, bizarrely “Six or seven?”

“I was here-briefly-in August 1999.”

“August 1999,” she repeated.

“Yes.” Harding shaped a smile. “Is that important?”

“Is this… something to do with the accident?”

“What accident?”

“I’ve told Ray Trathen. It’s nothing to do with me. It’s all in Isbister’s hands.”

Harding shook his head. “I’m sorry. I don’t understand. I bumped into Ray Trathen upstairs. Literally. He used to work for Barney Tozer, apparently. I’m over here on Barney’s behalf, actually. But-”

“You’re the guy he sent for the ring?”

“Yes. How did-”

“Mr. Isbister mentioned it. I know about the ring, of course. Gabriel told me. Look…” She pressed her hands together in a strange, almost prayerful gesture. “Do you want to come in? I’ve just made some tea. It’ll probably be stewed by now, but… you’re welcome to a cup.”

“OK. Thanks.”

The basement was a haven of neatness and order after the cluttered chaos of the rest of the house. Harding was shown into an antiquely equipped but spotlessly clean kitchen, glimpsing a simply furnished lounge and bedroom through open doors along the way. He found himself wondering how old Hayley Winter was. A lot younger than he was, certainly, but maybe not as young as she looked. There was something bemusingly mature yet childlike about her, something weathered but vulnerable.

She poured the tea, in cups and saucers rather than the mugs he might have expected. As she moved to the fridge to fetch the milk, he noticed just how slightly built she was. He tried to stop actively searching his memory for a trace of her. The recollection would come to him eventually, he felt sure. They stood either side of a large, bare, scrubbed table, sipped their tea and looked at each other.

“It’s quite a scrum up there,” said Harding.

“I’m trying to keep out of the way.”

“Good idea.”

“We really have never met, you know.”

“Not even in… August 1999?”

“I wasn’t here then.”

“But the date struck some kind of a chord with you.”

“Only because that’s when the accident was.”

“What accident was that?”

“It’s only what I’ve heard. Barney’s never mentioned it to you?”

“Was Barney involved?”

“Oh yes. He was there. He was very much involved. According to Ray Trathen, that’s why he-” She broke off, frowning again, more suspiciously than before. “Barney hasn’t told you?”

“No. He hasn’t. Why don’t you?”

“I don’t know. I mean, it’s common knowledge. Pretty common, anyway. But…”

“I won’t tell anyone I heard about it from you, Hayley If you don’t want me to.”

“I don’t mind. Why should I?” She bridled at the implication, then looked slightly abashed. “Sorry, I didn’t mean to… You really don’t know?”

“Not a thing.”

“But you’re a friend of Barney’s?”

“Friend. Employee. Bit of both. But the employee part’s strictly freelance. I’m doing him a favour where the ring’s concerned, that’s all. My day job is garden maintenance. Barney’s one of my clients.”

“Has he ever explained to you why he left Cornwall?”

“People move to Monaco for one reason and one reason only. To dodge the taxman.”

“I wouldn’t know about that. Gabriel reckoned he left because of the accident. And Ray Trathen will tell you the same.” She sat down at the table. Harding took the hint and sat down opposite her. “It’s none of my business, of course. None at all. It’s only what Gabriel said. It was a diving accident, off the Scillies, in August 1999.” Harding’s ears pricked up. The Scillies, in the summer of 1999, was where Barney had met Carol. “Barney was diving with a girl called Kerry Foxton. They were exploring a wreck. Anyway, there was some problem with Kerry’s oxygen supply. They got separated and she somehow became trapped underwater. By the time they’d found her and brought her to the surface, she’d stopped breathing. She was resuscitated, but had already suffered brain damage. She never recovered.”

“She died?”

“Some time later, yes. I don’t know the details. But a lot of people blamed Barney, apparently. He left for good not long after. Gabriel didn’t seem to think tax was the reason. Neither did anyone else. Officially, no one was blamed. But fingers were pointed. You know how it is. A tragedy like that has to be laid at someone’s door. And Barney was the more experienced diver. So…”

“Was Kerry Foxton from round here?”

“I’m not sure. Like I say, I don’t know the details. Ray Trathen’s the man to ask about that.”

“What makes him such an expert?”

“Well, he was-”

Hayley was cut off by the bleeping of Harding’s phone. Cursing himself for having left the thing switched on, he pulled it out of his pocket, spotted the caller’s number as Carol’s and switched it straight to voicemail. “Sorry. You were saying?”

“Just that Ray Trathen was on the boat they dived from.”

“He was?”

“I guess he didn’t drink so much then. And he was still working for Barney of course. Though not for much longer.”

“Are you saying that’s why Barney sacked him? Because he was a witness to what happened?”

“I’m not saying anything. But it’s what Ray says to anyone who’s willing to listen.”

“But surely if Barney was culpable in some way and Ray knew it, that would be a reason for not sacking him.”

“You’re right. It would.” Hayley smiled faintly. “The guy’s not strong on logic.”

“What did you mean earlier when you said you’d told him everything was in Isbister’s hands?”

“Well, it is. The auction, I mean. All Gabriel’s… things. Have you seen how much there is?”

“I’ve taken a look round, yes.”

“Did you spot the videos?”

“I… don’t think so.”

“In the drawing room. There’s a corner cupboard stacked with them. Hundreds, I should say. All unlabelled.”

“What’s on them?”

“Old documentaries. Gabriel loved that kind of thing. Global warming. Ancient civilization. Life on Mars. He’d watch stuff like that for hours.”

“What’s that to do with Ray Trathen?”

“It’s why he’s been round here so often lately making a nuisance of himself.” Hayley sighed, as if weary of the subject she was about to embark upon. “Ray claims he lent Gabriel a video a couple of years ago. He got it back. But then, recently, when he played it, he found what Gabriel had actually returned to him was, well, wouldn’t you guess, an old edition of Horizon.”

“Gabriel had recorded over it?”

“No, no. He never recorded over anything. That’s why there are so many. Ray claims Gabriel deliberately gave him back the wrong video so he could hang on to the one Ray had lent him.”

“Why would he want to do that?”

“Because of what was on it, I guess.”

“And what was that?”

“Ray’s not saying. Something important, apparently, something he badly wants back-but isn’t going to get unless he buys the entire collection at the auction. Assuming his video really is among them, of course. Assuming he hasn’t imagined the whole thing.”