The nurse smiled at her. “That’s Rascal. We tell the residents not to feed him,” she murmured. “But they can’t help themselves. He brings them such pleasure.”

“I’ll bet.” Liz returned her smile. “I’m looking for a resident named Father Paul Ramos. I was told he lived here.”

“He does.” She pointed. “He’s in C wing, number fourteen. If he’s lucid, he’ll be delighted to have a visitor.”

Liz’s heart sank. “If he’s lucid?”

“Father Paul’s one hundred and two. Sometimes he’s with us. And sometimes he’s not. So don’t be alarmed if he starts talking crazy.”

Liz found fourteen-C. Father Paul sat in his wheelchair, facing the window. A Bible lay open in his lap; his mouth worked as he moved the rosary beads between his fingers.

She tapped on the door. “Father Paul?”

He looked at her, squinting. “Margaret?”

“No.” She stepped into the room. “My name’s Elizabeth Ames. I was hoping I could ask you a few questions.”

“Come in, child.” He smiled and motioned her closer. “How can an old man like me help you?”

She perched on the edge of his bed and he swiveled his chair to face her. “I’m a counselor and one of my patients told me an interesting story. She said you could tell me more about it.”

He laughed, the sound papery with age. “I know many interesting stories, a benefit of having lived a long time.” He leaned toward her, expression almost childlike. “And I love telling them.”

She laughed too, liking this man. “This is a special story, Father. One about the Blessed Mother appearing to children in the churchyard of what is now Paradise Christian Church.”

His inclined his head, expression pleased. “That is, indeed, a special story.” He laid his rosary in his Bible, marking his place, then closed the book. “It is a true story, one I was told by my grandparents, children at the time.

“ Key West was very different at that time. Cut off from the rest of the country by water.”

He looked past her, expression faraway. “Did you know, at one time Key West was the wealthiest city in America?” He returned his gaze to hers. “It’s true. Because of the salvaging industry. Ships crashed into the reef and went down. The bells would sound and there would be a great race to see which outfit reached the sinking vessel first.”

“The first to the vessel rescued the passengers and claimed the ship’s bounty as their own,” she murmured. “Is that right?”

“It is, indeed.” His lips lifted. “There are rumors that some of Key West ’s more nefarious entrepreneurs actually lured the vessels to the reef.”

“And you believe those rumors are true.”

“One must be watchful of greed, child. There’s a reason it’s one of the seven deadly sins.”

He sobered. “The devil is crafty, indeed. He captures us through the things that make us most human. Lust. Pride. Anger. Avarice. Envy. Sloth. Gluttony. These we must guard against, just as the Lord warned us we should.”

Liz thought of Tara and shuddered. The light in Father Paul’s eyes was the same she had seen in the girl’s. Somehow, it seemed less disturbing in a man of Father Paul’s age and religious stature.

“I’ve frightened you,” he murmured.

She rubbed her arms. “No, of course not.”

“I wish I had.”

She blinked in surprise. “Excuse me?”

He looked past her once more, expression faraway. “I know, you didn’t come here to be warned against the Beast. No one does anymore. It’s not…fashionable.”

He fell silent. His eyes closed. Liz waited, wondering if he had fallen asleep. And if he had, if she should wake him or leave.

Suddenly, he opened his eyes and looked at her, his blue gaze as clear as a summer sky. “Back then, Paradise Christian was St. Stephen’s. And there in the walled garden, among the banyan and poinciana trees, the Blessed Mother appeared as a vision to the children. She didn’t speak, just hovered there, swathed in a halo as bright as the gold coins recovered from all those shipwrecked vessels. The children weren’t frightened. They were awed. They understood they were in the presence of God. They fell to their knees in prayer and thanksgiving. Several ran for Father Roberto.”

“Did he witness the vision?” she asked, spellbound.

The old priest shook his head. “He was too late. But he believed. After all, why would these children, good, faithful children, make such a thing up?

“For the next fourteen days,” he continued, “ Key West was blessed with one miracle after another. Sickness was cured. The blind could suddenly see, the crippled walk. Blood flowed from the hands of the statue of Christ.”

“And then the miracles stopped,” Liz whispered. “And the storm came.”

“Yes. The wind first, a gentle breeze from the west. The old-timers knew. The breeze, the movement of the water. Something was wrong. Word spread. A few packed up their families and made their way toward the mainland, from key to key by boat. Others refused to leave and instead began making preparations.

“Of course, as in all things, there were disbelievers. Naysayers. There would be no storm. The Lord had always spared this beautiful place, they believed he would spare her once more.”

But he didn’t spare her, Liz knew. She had read about this hurricane, thought the worst Key West had suffered. The year 1846 predated hurricane naming and classification systems, so it was called only the storm of 1846.

“Back then there was no early-warning system. No hurricane center in Miami. No Weather Channel.” His eyes clouded with the memory. “Only the church bells to ring. And only when it was already too late. The storm was all but upon them.”

Liz shivered, imagining. She knew from her reading that in those days the only way on and off the island was by boat. Flagler’s railroad didn’t open until 1912; the overseas highway not until 1938.

“For forty-eight hours the storm pummeled the island. With the scream of the wind could be heard the church bells and the cries of the lost ones. Many were washed out to sea, and for weeks afterward bodies floated ashore. Entire families, lashed together.” He lowered his voice. “Men, women and children. It’s a miracle that anyone was spared.”

“Your grandparents and their family were among the survivors.”

“Yes. They were protected. The Blessed Virgin protected them.”

Liz realized she was holding her breath and released it. “The church was destroyed.”

“Yes,” he murmured. “The church and all who had taken refuge there were washed out to sea.”

“So the archdiocese decided to demonize the visions.”

He shook his head, his expression unbearably sad. “The visions were a true miracle. Acts of God not demons. They were a warning to guard against the wicked, a warning of the approaching storm. The believers were saved.”

He lowered his voice to a crackly whisper. Liz leaned toward him, straining to hear. “The church lies on sacred ground. Listen well, child.” He reached out and caught her hand, his skin as dry as parchment, his grip surprisingly strong. “It is a profoundly holy place and must be protected at all costs. For in the desecration of the holy, evil extends its putrid grasp.”