“He had. She told me they’ve been separated for years. She runs an art shop in Copper City under her married name.”

Mackendrick penciled a note on a yellow pad. “Is Fred Johnson queer?”

“I doubt it. He has a girl.”

“You just got finished telling me that Grimes had a wife.”

“It’s true, Fred could be bisexual. But I’ve spent a fair amount of time with him now, and haven’t seen any evidence of it. Even if he is, it doesn’t make him a thief.”

“He stole a picture.”

“He took it with the knowledge and permission of the owner’s daughter. Fred is a budding art expert. He wanted to test the picture for age and authenticity.”

“So he says now.”

“I believe him. I honestly don’t think he belongs in jail.”

Mackendrick’s palm and fist came together again like parts of a machine. “Is Fred Johnson paying you to say this?”

“Biemeyer is paying me to recover his picture. Fred Johnson says he hasn’t got it. I think it’s time we looked elsewhere. In fact, that’s what I’ve been doing, more or less accidentally.”

Mackendrick waited. I told him what I had learned about Paul Grimes’s early life in Arizona, and about his relationship with Richard Chantry. I also told him about the death of Mildred Mead’s illegitimate son, William, and the quick departure of Richard Chantry from Arizona in the summer of 1943.

Mackendrick picked up his pencil and began to draw connected squares across the yellow paper, a series of squares like a random chessboard representing the precincts of the city or his mind.

“This is new information to me,” he admitted finally. “Are you sure that it’s good information?”

“I got most of it from the sheriff who handled the William Mead killing. You can check with him if you want to.”

“I’ll do that. I was in the army when Chantry came here and bought that house on the ocean. But I got out and joined the force in 1945 and I was one of the few people who got to know him personally.” Mackendrick spoke as if his own experience and the history of the city had become almost synonymous to him. “I patrolled the beach front there for several years, until I made sergeant. That was how I became acquainted with Mr. Chantry. He was very security-conscious. He did a lot of complaining about people loitering around his house. You know how the beach and the ocean always attract out-of-towners.”

“Was he nervous?”

“I guess you’d say that. He was a loner, anyway. I never knew him to give a party, or even invite friends into his house. As far as I knew, he had no friends. He kept himself locked up in that house with his wife and a man called Rico, who cooked for them. And he worked. As far as I know, all he did was work. Sometimes he’d be up painting all night and I’d see the lights still burning in his house when I cruised by on the early-morning shift.” Mackendrick lifted his eyes, which had been emptied of the present and now became filled and perplexed by it again. “Are you sure that Mr. Chantry was a homo? I never knew one of them who liked hard work.”

I didn’t mention Leonardo for fear of confusing the issue. “I’m fairly certain. You could ask around.”

Mackendrick shook his head abruptly. “Not in this town I couldn’t. He’s Santa Teresa’s claim to fame—gone for twenty-five years, and still our leading citizen. And you be careful what you say about him.”

“Is that a threat?”

“It’s a warning. I’m doing you a favor giving it. Mrs. Chantry could sue you, and don’t think she wouldn’t. She’s got the local paper so bulldozed that they let her read it ahead of time whenever they mention her husband. Especially when they mention his disappearance, it has to be handled with kid gloves.”

“What do you think happened to him, Captain? I’ve told you what I know.”

“And I appreciate it. If he was a homo, as you say he was, then there’s your answer right there. He stayed with his wife for seven years and couldn’t stick it any longer. It’s one thing I’ve often noticed about homos. Their lives run in cycles; they can’t stay the course. And they have a tougher course to run than most of us.”

Mackendrick had succeeded in surprising me. There was a vein of tolerance in his granite after all.

I said, “Is that the official theory, Captain? That Chantry simply took off of his own accord. No murder? No suicide? No blackmailing pressure?”

Mackendrick took in a deep whistling breath through his nose, and blew it out through his lips. “I wouldn’t attempt to tell you how many times I’ve been asked that question. It’s just about my favorite question by now,” he said with irony. “And I always give the same answer. We never came up with any evidence at all that Chantry had been killed, or forced to leave. As far as we were able to establish the facts, Chantry left here because he wanted to start a new life. And what you tell me about his sexual background only confirms it.”

“I assume his farewell letter was checked out in every way.”

“Every way possible. Handwriting, fingerprints, source of stationery—everything. The writing and the prints and the stationery were all Chantry’s. There was no evidence that the letter was written under duress, either. And no new evidence has come up in the twenty-five years since then. I’ve had a special interest in the case from the beginning, because I knew Chantry, and you can take my word for all this. For some reason, he got sick and tired of his life here in Santa Teresa, and he dropped out.”

“He may have dropped in again, Captain. Fred Johnson seems to think that the stolen picture is a Chantry, and a fairly recent one.”

Mackendrick made an impatient flinging gesture with his left hand. “I’d want a better opinion than Fred Johnson’s. And I don’t buy his story that the picture was stolen from the museum. I think he’s got it stashed someplace. If it is a genuine Chantry, it’s worth real money. And in case you don’t know it, Fred Johnson’s family is on the rocks financially. His father’s a hopeless drunk who hasn’t worked for years; his mother lost her job at the hospital under suspicion of stealing drugs. And no matter whether he lost it or sold it or gave it away, Fred is criminally responsible for the loss of that picture.”

“Not until he’s proved responsible.”

“Don’t give me that, Archer. Are you a lawyer?”

“No.”

“Then stop trying to act the part of one. Fred is where he belongs. You’re not. And I have an appointment with the deputy coroner.”

I thanked Mackendrick for his patience, without irony. He had told me a number of things I needed to know.

Leaving the police station, I passed my friend Purvis coming in. The young deputy coroner had the bright glazed look of a dedicated public servant on his way to get his picture in the paper. He didn’t even break stride as he went by.

I waited beside his official station wagon. Squad cars came and went. A flock of starlings flew over in a twittering cloud, and the first early shadow of evening followed them across the sky. I was worried about what might happen to Fred in jail, and regretful that I hadn’t been able to spring him.

Purvis came out of the station eventually, walking more slowly, with a certain weight of confidence.

I said, “What’s the word?”

“Remember the cadaver I showed you the night before last in the morgue?”

“I’m not likely to forget him. Jacob Whitmore, the painter.”

Purvis nodded. “He wasn’t drowned in the ocean after all.

We completed a very careful autopsy this afternoon. Whitmore was drowned in fresh water.”

“Does that mean he was murdered?”

“Probably. Mackendrick seems to think so. Drowned in somebody’s bathtub and chucked into the ocean afterwards.”

^chapter

27

I drove out to Sycamore Point and knocked on the door of Jacob Whitmore’s cottage. It was opened by the girl he had left behind. The low sun touched her face with a rosy glow and made her narrow her eyes. She didn’t appear to recognize me.