Lefty had vouched for me, and surely Sonny had checked me out with guys on Mulberry Street. Still, he would have to buy me face-to-face. If I didn’t convince Sonny Black that I was who I said I was, if I didn’t give him the right impression, if I gave him any doubts at all, the whole case would come to a halt. If I played my part right, I might gain direct access to him without having to go through Lefty or anybody else, as I had had to with Mike Sabella.

Rossi and I met them at the airport. Lefty, Sonny, and Sonny’s girlfriend, Judy. Lefty and I shook hands and kissed each other on the cheek. Lefty says, “Sonny, Donnie.” Sonny and I kissed each other. I say, “Sonny, this is Tony, he’s with me. Tony, Sonny.” Sonny shook Rossi’s hand.

We took them to Malio’s Restaurant in Tampa for dinner and then to King’s Court.

Sonny, in his late forties, was a sturdy 5’7”, about 170 pounds, with a powerfully developed chest and arms. On his right arm was a tattoo of a panther. He was swarthy, with hair he dyed jet-black-hence his nickname. His face was fleshy, with rings under the eyes that made him look, depending upon his mood, either tired or menacing. When he fixed his dark eyes on you, either in anger or to give an order, he could freeze anybody. Everything dark about him got darker, and nothing was soft. Yet in contrast to Lefty, Sonny had a laid-back style. He radiated confidence, control, and power, but not arrogance. He was younger than Mike Sabella, more observant, harder. He noticed everything. I paid close attention to everything he said. He had a reputation for personal loyalty, a guy who would kill you in a minute if you crossed him.

After a tour of King’s Court, Sonny took me aside to a table apart from the others.

“Donnie, before I came here, I did some checking. Talked to some guys from downtown that know you. They say good things about you. Lefty says good things about you. They tell me you’re the kind of guy, you do your business and keep your mouth shut and don’t bother people and don’t make a scene about anything. You’re a good earner and you’re not flamboyant. I like that. From now on you can report to me. You don’t have to report to Lefty.”

“I’m flattered.”

“What do you want to do down here?”

“Maybe some bookmaking and shylocking.”

“Good. Our people in New York will back it. You want me to send somebody down to help you start the loan-sharking operation?”

“I don’t think so. I got a guy I brought in, Chico, to oversee things here. I trust him.” “Chico” was an undercover agent we had made the general overseer of the club so that Rossi and I could be free to go back and forth to New York when we needed to.

“How much do you need to start a shylock operation?”

“Maybe twenty-five grand.”

“What’s the vig rate down here?”

Vigorish is the interest on shylock loans. “Tony says it’s four or five points, depending on the customer and the size of the loan. We’d also like to move into Orlando. ”

“When we’re ready here, then we can go into Orlando. I got somebody looking into Orlando. I like what I see here so far, the club layout. It looks like we can make a lot of money here. Donnie, remember this: We can all earn. When we’re doing business among friends, we all share everything equally and we don’t try to cheat each other. We got an army up in New York behind us. Nobody can bother us as long as we conduct ourselves in the proper manner.”

Sonny’s approach to me—telling me I could report to him—put me in a difficult position. If I had been a legitimate badguy, I would have jumped at the chance to hook up directly to a captain and rise up the ladder. But as an agent, I couldn’t jeopardize the operation. If Lefty got angry with me, he could have engineered a squelch of the whole King’s Court deal. On the one hand, I couldn’t appear to be defying Sonny. On the other hand, I had to stay loyal to Lefty. I had to tell him about Sonny’s approach before he heard it from somebody else. And I had to tell him in such a way that I would be protected if my words got back to Sonny. Whatever Sonny heard about me had to include that I was a stand-up guy.

First thing the next morning I sat Lefty down and told him what Sonny had said. “But I’m still going to be loyal to you,” I say. “Anything that I do with Sonny, I’m gonna run it by you, because you and me started together.”

“I’m happy you say that,” Lefty says. “But who does this guy think he is if he thinks he can take you away from me? He ain’t got no right to you.”

The next day we all lounged around the pool at the Tahitian, and Sonny continued to encourage plans. He suggested that a good way to work the bookmaking and shylocking was by using a coffee truck that delivered to construction sites. The driver could run the business right out of the truck. He wanted us to have a Las Vegas Night, a popular event where the gambling is supposedly for charity.

“Once we have a Vegas Night,” Sonny says, “then it becomes ours. Nobody else can have it. Start lining it up. I’ll send wheels and stuff down from New York.”

I am an avid reader. In this job especially, I was an avid newspaper reader. I read whatever newspapers I could get my hands on. The guys would say “Give Donnie the newspapers and he sits in a corner and he’s happy all day.”

But I wasn’t always reading just to read. It was a good cover. While I was reading the New York Post or The New York Times or the Daily News from cover to cover, I was listening to their conversations. I was seeming to read so my listening was not obvious.

When I was away from New York, whether I was in Milwaukee or California or Florida, Lefty always would bring me the New York Post and the Daily News for that day. He never missed. He would get off a plane, and the first thing he’d do was hand me those newspapers.

One time I picked him up at the Tampa airport and we were driving to the hotel. It dawned on me that he hadn’t given me anything. “Left, where are my newspapers?”

“You won’t fucking believe what happened, Donnie. I’m sitting there on the plane reading the Daily News, and there’s this Indian sitting next to me.”

“What do you mean, Indian?”

“One of them guys with the towels on their head.”

“Oh, you don’t mean an American Indian, you mean a guy from India.”

“He’s a fucking Indian, I don’t know where he’s from. Got a big towel on his head. Don’t matter where he’s from. He’s an Indian.”

“So what about the newspapers?”

“I’m reading the paper, reading an article about Ted Kennedy. This guy’s leaning over all the time, looking at the paper. He says, ‘What do you think of Ted Kennedy?’ I ignore him. He don’t even speak English, broken English. He repeats it. I say, ‘Hey, Charlie, do I know you? What the fuck you care what I think about Ted Kennedy?’

“I finish reading the News and put it down and start reading the Post. This guy touches the paper, Donnie! He starts leafing through my Daily News. When I put the Post down, he touches that too. I wouldn’t bring these papers to you after that towel-head touches them.”

“Left, nine million people touch that newspaper.”

“Donnie, I don’t know what this Indian’s got. He could have any disease. I wouldn’t let you touch the same newspaper as this Indian. I left those fucking newspapers right on the plane.”

Everyplace we went, Lefty had Rossi pick up the tab. Lefty would bring guests for dinner, Rossi would have to pick up the tab. Rossi went to the mall to pick up some shaving stuff, Lefty would join him, pile the cart high with poolside gear and toiletries, and Rossi would pay at the checkout.

It was Lefty’s birthday. You always exchange birthday and Christmas presents with guys you’re close to in the crew. It’s expected. This day I don’t say anything. I don’t even wish him happy birthday. I just let him stew.