Frances could sense Collin watching her as she studied the picture, which only increased her resolution not to waver. ‘The cut was made from the left side of the throat to the right?’ she asked.

‘Yes. In all probability he was approached from behind by a right-handed man, who clasped him about the head with his left arm, pulling it back quickly before he could defend himself, so exposing the throat, and then drew the knife across once.’ Dr Collin mimed the gesture. ‘A practiced hand and a firm one. It is a common technique amongst footpads.’

‘And you are quite sure that this is not the body of Mr Antrobus?’ queried Frances, since it was hard to see who it might have been.

‘I cannot be sure one way or the other. Although Mr Antrobus was my patient he never consulted me about his personal health and I never examined him. I was only consulted regarding his wife. I therefore have no special knowledge to offer.’

‘There was nothing unusual you observed about his health during your normal conversation which could have assisted the court?’

‘Nothing at all. He appeared to be robust and active, in the prime of life, sensible and sane. I never saw any reason to suggest that he required medical attention.’

Frances looked more carefully at the picture. ‘I can see no hair or whiskers on the remains. The picture I have of Mr Antrobus shows that he had both.’

‘Any hair may have become detached by soaking in water before the adipocere was formed.’

‘Was there nothing to be learned from the teeth?’

‘The teeth in the upper jaw provided no clues since they had been greatly neglected. I doubt that this man has seen a dentist in many years. But cowards may be of any class. The lower jaw is missing as are most of the long bones.’ Collin leaned forward to study the picture closely, his fingertips tracing the spine, the vertebrae held together only by being sunken into fatty tissue. ‘The spine shows no deformities, the ribs’ – he indicated them with a double sweep of his fingers – ‘nothing remarkable.’

Frances did not wish Edwin Antrobus any ill, but perversely, how she might have wished him to have had a small scar on his cheek or an unusual birthmark, or curiously shaped ears, or anything that might have enabled someone who knew him to see these horrible fragments and say yes or no. But it was not to be.

Thankfully for her aching feet, which had borne her many miles on a busy day, she could look forward to Sunday, when she would need to walk no further than St Stephen’s church.

CHAPTER EIGHT

Despite her weariness after a taxing day, Frances slept badly, her slumbers disturbed by horrid dreams of being crushed by a powerful evil-smelling figure from whom there was no escape. In church the following morning Sarah twice had to nudge her when it seemed that she was about to slip into a doze. She was far from being the ever-alert Miss Doughty she was sometimes reputed to be and was only sorry that she was not more like the daring Miss Dauntless of the stories who was able to face any challenge by day or night without the need for sleep at all.

Sunday afternoon was a time for reflection on the week past and the week ahead. Frances had learned a great deal about Edwin Antrobus, his business and his family but nothing that suggested to her what his fate might have been. There were still two servants to trace but when that was done she could think of no one else to whom she might speak.

Rereading her notes she was reminded that the missing man’s uncle was thought to have died by his own hand, an incident that had cast a shadow over the marriage. She resolved to return to the Chronicle offices next morning to read the report of the inquest. Was the family taint on the husband’s side and not the wife’s? Had Edwin Antrobus managed to show a face of sanity to hide his true madness and melancholy?

There was also a new client to see, a report to write and invoices to dispatch, but more happily, she would be entertaining her uncle Cornelius to tea. With that thought she retired to bed early and thankfully awoke refreshed.

On Monday morning Frances received a letter from Matthew Ryan, the Bristol detective. He had learned nothing new about the disappearance of Edwin Antrobus in the three years since his initial report, but in the light of recent events he was making fresh enquiries. An appeal for information would soon appear in all the Bristol newspapers with a full description and an engraving of the missing man drawn from a photograph, asking most particularly if he had been seen in the company of another man and whether, either alone or accompanied, he had boarded the train to Paddington.

Frances’ new client was a lady, a Mrs Reville, youthful, beautiful and refined in her speech and manners, who told Frances that her husband was taking proceedings for divorce on the grounds of infidelity. She protested, with tears in her eyes, that she had always been a true and faithful wife, and he had no proof at all of any wrongdoing but claimed that she had given him a disease he could have contracted in no other way. She had appealed to the family doctor, who had refused to tell her anything about her husband’s condition on the grounds of confidentiality and could only conclude that, despite his strident denials, it was her husband who had been faithless and passed the disease to her. This was not grounds for her to divorce him, and in any case she had no wish to do so as she still loved him and forgave him everything, but if she were cast aside then she would never again be permitted to see her four children.

Frances agreed to take the case, but she thought how useless it would be to have either husband or wife followed to discover which one was being truthful as both would be on their guard. The hearing was due to come to court in three weeks, so there was very little time to achieve anything.

At the offices of the Chronicle, Frances read the report of the inquest on Edwin Antrobus’ maternal uncle, thirty-seven-year-old Mr Charles Henderson, which had taken place in Paddington on 14 September 1863. The principal witness was his nephew, then aged twenty-six, who had found the body. Although the young man had borne himself well in court, the Chronicle’s report stated that from time to time he could not refrain from shedding tears and attracted considerable sympathy.

Charles Henderson had died three days earlier at a family gathering at his home on Craven Hill. It had been an informal dinner, attended by a Mr Pearce, who was accompanied by his wife and two daughters and Mr Henderson’s elderly aunts. During the course of the evening the party had removed to the drawing room, and there had been some conversation on the subject of ornamental snuffboxes, since Mr Henderson collected them, and he offered to show the company a new acquisition that was in a glass case in his study. The study was locked, and he said he would fetch the key and return shortly. Several minutes passed before one of the aunts commented that her nephew was taking a long time and she thought he must have mislaid the key.

About a minute or two later there was a gunshot that appeared to come from within the house. Edwin Antrobus, telling the rest of the party to remain where they were, went out into the hallway and called up the stairs to his uncle, but there was no reply. He ran up to the study and found the door open, his uncle slumped across the desk and a recently discharged pistol and its polishing cloth on the floor beside him. He had been shot through the temple.