“Ana …” said James. Her trust in authority made James’s stomach churn. In the look on his face, pained and nauseated, Ana saw suddenly what he was afraid of, saw holes that they might slip inside, court rooms, a boy removed. But had she not recognized this possibility when she handed over the number? Perhaps she had. Perhaps she was orchestrating a quick, swift conclusion. Was she now this kind of person? But no, she told herself, I just want to do it aboveboard. I just want to be honest.

And James next to her could feel her cycling through these thoughts, could see her abiding every formality, filling in every blank, and he loathed her, he loathed her. She was risking everything.

They sat there as the police officers spoke, and both Ana and James silently arrived at the exact same thought, bristling with shame: I am not sure what I am capable of anymore.

James said the things he had said several times in the past hour, perfecting his description of Finn. Each time he said it out loud—the panda suit, the black boots, the yellow-and-gray-striped T-shirt underneath—the horror grew a little more pronounced. Finn became smaller, farther away from him. The outside became darker.

“What do you do in cases like this?” asked Ana. “How will you find him?”

“We’ll engage all resources, ma’am,” said the woman cop. The woman cop spoke to Ana, and the man to James.

“What does that mean?”

“We’ll need to interview you both,” said the male cop.

“Now?” asked James. “I need to look. I need to be out there.”

In concert, the cops’ faces had narrowed from sympathetic to something distant, aloof. This shift began around the time James had mentioned the fact that they weren’t Finn’s parents. Ana saw them through the eyes of the police. She saw the house, white and empty (the housekeeper had come; it was so damned tidy), the childless couple within it, tourists to parenting. What had they done to deserve this boy? What did they know of little boys? She thought of Marcus, young and at the hands of his father, the scar below his lip. She thought of unknown little boys lured to drainpipes by bearded men. She saw James at the bottom of the ladder of images just because he was a man with a beard sitting next to his barren wife.

“Do we need to get a lawyer?” she asked. “I’m a lawyer. I can make a call.”

James turned to her. “What? That seems a little premature.”

“We’re not arresting you,” said the female cop. “We just need some information.”

“I think we should get a lawyer,” said Ana. “I’ll call Elspeth. No—I’ll call Rick.”

“What are you talking about? Ana, my God.” He turned to the officers, both of whom had assumed a studied blankness. “We’re happy to talk to you. We’re doing it right now.”

Ana said nothing.

“If it’s all right, I’ll talk to you in the kitchen,” said the male police officer, standing. James followed him.

“Can we shut the door?” The officer looked around for a door.

“Open concept,” said James. He led him to the breakfast nook by the garden, where two people continued to search behind plants that had been searched behind already.

The officer took out a small notebook, clicked his pen. James began to sweat, rivulets from his Adam’s apple down to his chest hair.

The officer asked him the time, the outfit, the names of friends. James moved through each question dully, feeling the water seeping through his shirt, approaching his sweater. His beard began to itch from the sweat.

“So he’s your nephew?” said the cop.

“No. He’s the son of a friend who died. His mother’s in the hospital.” The cop nodded, wrote in his blue scratch.

“And is everything okay with him here? Any fights or anything out of the ordinary this morning?” The bluntness of the question surprised James. He expected it to be gently bracketed: I’m sorry to ask you this, but …

“Yes. I mean, as okay as it can be. His father died. He’s living with strangers.…” The cop paused, began to write.

“Don’t write that down. We’re not strangers. You know what I mean. We’re not family. We’re not his real family. But we love him like he’s our real family. Please don’t write the word ‘strangers’—I—” James was exploding with the need to get out of the kitchen, on to the streets. He could find him, he was certain. Finn would want to be found by James. He would rise like a gas from the cracks in the sidewalks, pull himself up from the gutters where he was hiding, and make himself solid and seen for James. “Please let me go look for him.”

The woman cop grinned at Ana, like a girlfriend happy the husbands have left the kitchen.

Ana found the constant shifts in the woman’s demeanor ridiculous, something studied on television. She craned her neck and saw James facing the cop across the nook table far away. They could be two guys waiting for the coffee to drip, except for the cop’s bowed head as he wrote.

“When did you last see Finn?” asked the cop, still smiling.

“This morning. No, last night. I was gone before he got up.”

“So your husband got him up?”

“Yes.”

“He fed him, dressed him, took him to school?”

“He doesn’t go to school. He goes to daycare three days a week. James took him.”

“We’ll need to get the number of the daycare.” The cop clicked her pen, flipped open a rubbery notepad like a small medical chart. She wrote something, shielding the paper from Ana. “So Mr. Ridgemore took him to daycare. Does he do that most days?”

“I told you. Three days a week.”

“I mean, he’s the one who gets him up?”

“I have to be at work very early. James works from home.”

“What does he do again?” She asked this in a false voice, the “again” a silly little effort at intimacy.

“He’s a writer.”

“Lucky you. Husband does all the hard stuff, huh?” She smiled. Ana wanted to snap off her teeth, one by one.

“Did he call you today? Tell you anything about the boy?”

“Like what?”

“Did they have a fight? Anything unusual?”

“No. I don’t think I heard from him today.” The cop raised her eyebrow.

“Really? I got two kids, eight and ten, boy and a girl. If their dad’s with them, I’m calling every ten minutes: How are they? What’d you screw up? What’d I miss?” She was grinning. “They go to my mom’s after school. We never had to put them in daycare. We’re lucky like that.”

Ana said nothing, attempting to dissect this line of questioning, wondering if it was a strategy of some kind, or if the strain of contempt was how mothers were expected to talk to one another.

The cop held her gaze steady. After a moment of silence, she said: “Is there anything you want to say that you can’t tell me in front of your husband?”

Ana’s disdain for this cop and her simple view of the world rose up in her throat: The beautiful house must have the dungeon in the basement. The beautiful wife must barely survive the monstrous husband.

“There’s nothing I can’t say in front of him.”

The woman cop looked at Ana expectantly. Ana was meant to crucify him now, and she could have. She thought of the e-mail, and the secret visits to Sarah’s room. But she said: “James is a good father to this boy.”

The cop nodded. She didn’t write anything in her notebook.

“You should write that down: He’s a father to that boy. He would never neglect him. He would never hurt him. This is a freak occurrence, something that must happen every Halloween. Children try to get candy, they try to make their way without their parents, right? That’s what kids do.”

“Absolutely, Mrs. Laframboise. Is there someone we can call to corroborate your being at work today?”

Ana found Elspeth’s number on her cell phone and handed it to the cop.

“Now please,” said Ana. “Can you stop talking and find him?”

Voices echoed up and down the street: “Finn! Finn! Finn!” People whom James had never seen before were crouched next to cars, banging on doorways.