Roosevelt thrust a rigid index finger toward Dutch. “Have you changed your mind? Do you want to file a complaint and press charges against Mr. De Morès?”

“No. No law stuff.”

Roosevelt returned to his gaze to Joe. “There you have it. It would appear there’s little to be done.”

“We could organize a party and hang him for murder.”

“Not without due process of law, by thunder! Not while there are men of civilized decency left alive!” Roosevelt dismounted. As he led the horse toward the barn he called back over his shoulder, “Are you ready to head west in the morning?”

“Sure enough,” Joe replied without enthusiasm.

Roosevelt had tolled him into this two days ago when he’d returned on the train from back East. The New Yorker wanted to go out on a hunting expedition before the onset of winter. He wanted Joe Ferris with him. Joe didn’t care to go hunting but it seemed a prudent time to be away from town for a while; anyhow he needed money to keep the store alive; so he had agreed, after McKenzie and Pack had offered to take turns looking after the store in his absence.

Roosevelt had been in a good mood in spite of the fact that he had the other arm in a sling. Seemed he’d no sooner arrived on Long Island than he’d gone out on a hunt, following the hounds, and his horse had pitched him into a stream, breaking some bone or other in his arm. It really wasn’t safe to allow the poor dude near any sort of horse.

But Roosevelt had been cheerful when he’d stepped off the train and he couldn’t wait to set out into the wilderness.

Joe couldn’t help wondering what had perked him up so. He knew of few things that could have such an effect. Strong drink and pretty women, mainly. Joe knew this much: Roosevelt didn’t drink.

Did he have a woman back East?

If he did, he wasn’t talking about her.

In the morning Dutch Reuter came along. Dutch drove the wagon; he was to be mainly the cook. Bill Sewall was invited to accompany the hunters but the old Mennonite stayed behind to help young Dow look after the ranch—he said he preferred that to traveling the endless boring prairie.

It was easy to see by the way he moved that Roosevelt was favoring the injured arm. Nevertheless he was carrying his entire armory. “I want a grizzly bear above all. And a mature buffalo—a great bison bull.”

Joe made a face.

They came across the cabin at midmorning, that first day out. Joe remembered the place all too well. From the outset that shack had been fated ill.

Mr. Roosevelt said, “I’ve passed this place a score of times and always wondered about it. It seems sound enough. Why doesn’t someone live in it?”

“It happens you’re asking the right man that question, sir. I can tell you the whole sorry story of this miserable excuse for a house.”

Joe went on to tell it:

Two years ago in the railroad-building days, someplace nearly two hundred miles away south in the Short Pine Hills, some poor fool had thought to make his fortune cutting logs for ties. The fool aimed to float the ties north down the Little Missouri and sell them to the NPRR.

He was a fool because he should have asked. Anybody could have told him not to trust that river.

A storm had swelled the Little Missouri; the fool had lost control of his ties—the binding ropes snapped, his rafts splintered into giant toothpicks, and after wild rides the logs had been tossed helter-skelter onto riverbanks from here to Louisiana.

No one knew how fate had disposed of the fool. May be he’d been swept along in the flood; may be he’d given up in good cheer and gone farther west.

One accumulation of ties got trapped in a whirlpool eddy at a sharp bend 25 miles north of Medora town. When the flood subsided it left the stack of logs high and drying.

That was two years ago; Joe remembered it because he had camped here with Dutch and a hunting party, waiting out the storm. As they’d broken camp, Dutch had made a note of the location of the lumber pile. Then a couple of months later when the wood was mostly dried Joe had helped him set the ties on end like stockade fencing and they’d packed the chinks with mud and laced a sod roof across it and hung a horseshoe points-up over the doorway. They had nailed paper over the window openings and Dutch had talked vaguely about settling his wife here but then Deacon and Mrs. Osterhaut had offered fifty dollars for the place, which was far more than its worth, and without a second thought Dutch accepted the money.

Dutch would have kept it all, too. Joe remembered having words with him in Big Mouth Bob’s Bug Juice Dispensary. It had required three drinks’ worth of reasoning, after which Dutch had parted with a double eagle and a half eagle. They’d shaken hands and bought more drinks and forgiven each other. At the drunken end of the evening they’d lurched outside into the darkness and been rolled by a hard-breathing villain who had escaped in the dark with their gold pieces.

Joe always suspected Jerry Paddock had done the deed but he couldn’t honestly swear he’d recognized the man by sight or by scent, dark as it was and drunk as he was.

So no profit had come, after all, from the cabin of ties. It had started hard-luck and stayed that way.

Joe had gone back to work hunting. Dutch had disappeared into the wilderness according to his habit.

Now, riding beside Roosevelt, Joe looked back at the wagon to make sure Dutch was not in earshot; then he reined closer to Roosevelt and confided, “You know, sometimes Dutch ain’t the most reliable of men.”

Joe liked him anyhow. He’d put up with Dutch for a whole season during which they had provided the NPRR construction crews and dining-car passengers with fresh-killed venison for five cents a pound.

When it got to be too much killing for Joe he quit. But nothing seemed to get Dutch down. He was what flap-eared Arthur Packard called a free soul.

There was for example the time when Joe and Dutch rode across the tracks complaining of the heat and noticed an eastbound passenger train approaching in the distance—and the next thing Joe knew, Dutch was flagging down the train.

It labored to a juddering halt with great effort. When the engineer shouted down at Dutch, inquiring what the emergency was, Dutch only waved with great cheer, climbed aboard the dining car and helped himself to a pitcher of ice-water.

Joe watched from his saddle while, in the face of the train crew’s outrage, Dutch leaped off the train, still clutching the silver pitcher of ice-water. He drank deep and then proffered it up to his companion but Joe didn’t have the nerve and only shook his head. Dutch had another swallow and then tossed the pitcher up into the hands of the surprised conductor. He said in his German accent, “The alkali water in the river I don’t like. Thank you,” and made a cheerful bow of thanks before he gathered the reins and mounted.

Joe remembered how he’d cringed as they rode away followed by shouted threats upon the safety of their persons.

He remembered it all as they approached the cabin he and Dutch had built. Its luck hadn’t changed. It stood abandoned, weeds crowding the doorway, windows gaping vacantly. Joe said, “I’m not sure if it’s still Osterhaut’s.”

“What happened, then?”

“Ever put your nose in the door?” Joe replied.

Dutch watched with amusement. Roosevelt reined toward the cabin. The sorrel tried to shy away. Controlling it with difficulty the Easterner bent low to peer inside. “I don’t see anything.”

Dutch said, “Go closer.”

The horse balked. Roosevelt sank his heels. “Great Scott!” He lashed the rein-ends across its flanks; it only shied back.

“It doesn’t like something—”

There was a gust of wind. The sorrel all but pitched its rider; just the same, Joe saw it when the stink hit Roosevelt’s nostrils: his face contorted violently. The nervous horse backed up.