With an uneven sigh, Regina clasped Henry’s full mug and approached his booth. Sometime in the past five seconds, her neck and back had begun to perspire. Just as she placed it in front of Mr. Clayton, Elizabeth entered and, upon seeing Regina, panic flooded her eyes. She shook her head, but it was too late.

And it didn’t matter anyway, because Regina would have given it to him regardless of Elizabeth’s protest.

As Mr. Clayton lowered the paper and brought the coffee carefully to his mouth, he caught sight of the two of them, exchanging looks. A conversation between eyes. Regina’s screamed, Play along! His own flitted back and forth between them, trying to solve the mystery. Quickly, almost shamefully, Elizabeth looked to her feet and walked around Regina, taking an unassuming place at the counter. A place she would be able to hear them from.

“Anything you want to tell me, Mrs. Washington?” he asked, his voice colder than usual, and laced with suspicion.

She swallowed, smiling brightly. “Course not, Mr. Clayton.”

After studying her, he nodded; then as anticipation roiled in Regina’s belly, he took the first sip. Pulling the mug away with a knitted brow, he eyed it as though it was poison. Regina’s stomach dropped. They were doomed.

“What is this?” he demanded.

“Coffee, Mr. Clayton. I mean, real coffee.”

In an experimental manner, he brought it to his mouth, more carefully than the first time. He appeared to be savoring it, letting it live on his palate a moment—the same way Regina had earlier. “It’s…” He took another sip then shook his head. He actually smiled, ever so subtly, and what a handsome smile it was. “Well, it’s…damn good.” More loudly, he said, “The only good thing about my morning thus far.” It wasn’t hard to see the comment was meant for Elizabeth’s ears, since his eyes fixed on her back. Poor Elizabeth. Mean, ornery Mr. Clayton.

Regina faked a smile. “You like it then?”

“You’re really onto something.” After taking another sip, he actually addressed Elizabeth by name. “Ms. Ashton.” With a slightly compressed jaw and a hint of reluctance, Elizabeth turned. “Try this.” Everyone who eavesdropped paused mid-action. To one who didn’t know the events of that morning, Regina supposed such a request coming from Mr. Clayton would be strange.

“There’s no need for that, Mr. Clayton,” Elizabeth said.

“Please,” he argued, more clipped. “I insist.”

He and Elizabeth glared at each other, but eventually she joined them. “I…already tried it,” she said.

“Good. Then you know we don’t need better coffee here. Not sure any better exists.” He took another sip, slowly, and Regina swore she heard him groan as his eyes rolled to the back of his head. Of course, he didn’t know that by playing it up, he dug his own grave. “This is what we’ve been missing, Mrs. Washington.”

Elizabeth took another step, and despite Regina’s nudge she began, “Mr. Clayton—”

“That’s all, Ms. Ashton.” He went back to reading his paper before she could confess, and murder brewed in Elizabeth’s eyes. Regina pulled her away.

Once a safe distance away, Elizabeth whispered, “I can’t do this. He’s going to hate me even more for tricking him. And you too, Regina.”

Regina grabbed her slender arms. “Trust me, Beth. It’ll work. Now, for the finishing touch.” She took the plate from behind the counter, at the same time Elizabeth put her head in her hands. A single cream puff pastry, whose only decoration was a light drizzle of chocolate sauce, adorned the plate. It was elegant in its simplicity, yet delectable in its rich flavor and harmonious textures: creamy and sweet on the inside, light and flaky on the outside. It was the first thing Regina had made Elizabeth do that morning, when the sky was still dark: bake her finest pastry. And it was fine. Exquisite just like the coffee, and what a combo they would be.

She walked past Elizabeth, ignoring the warning daggers that shot from her narrow eyes. Looks of envy filled everyone else’s eyes, Brian’s especially as he stood to get a better view. “I’ll take one,” he said. Regina only glared at him, but his comment grabbed Mr. Clayton’s attention. He stared at her warily, like he’d done after tasting the first sip of coffee. She placed it before him and he recoiled from it.

“Mrs. Washington, what is going on here?”

“Well, it’s a cream puff pastry, Mr. Clayton. I thought you’d be able to recognize that.”

He sighed, just barely. “I’m aware of what a profiterole is. But never, in all the years you’ve been here, have you served a pastry.”

“It’s nothing, Mr. Clayton. Just try it. It’s on the house.” Her hands shook; she placed them behind her back. “Well, go ahead now.”

His jaw shifted as he deliberated, probably wondering why she wanted to be an audience to his tasting it. Still, he picked it up, taking a bite small and large at the same time—small for a man of his size but large for such a pastry. Less than half remained. He finished chewing, swallowed, and then said, “It’s…”

“Yes?”

“I don’t…have words.”

“That good?”

“Beyond delicious. Now tell me what this is about.”

“You think this is something our residents would enjoy? Would you personally, for example, love to see this on a normal basis?”

“Are you asking for my approval?”

“I suppose so.”

“Then…yes. It would do well. Is that all?”

“Well, go on and finish it then, Mr. Clayton.”

He did, and though he was guarded, his eyes said it all: it was heaven in his mouth.

“Good. Then I think we can both agree Ms. Ashton would be an invaluable addition to this town. Something like this—coffee like that—is needed here. You said so yourself, Mr. Clayton. And let’s face it: we ain’t really a part of Oregon until we’ve mastered the art of coffee brewing in our town, are we?”

His face darkened while his temples pulsated with the grinding of his jaw. If she had been any more scared, she would have seen her life flash before her eyes, mostly the bits with Nathaniel and her only son. But she stood her ground, even as he rose.

“You can fire me if you’d like, Mr. Clayton—”

“No,” Elizabeth interjected, moving to Regina’s side. Really, she stood in front of her in a protective manner. “This wasn’t her idea, Mr. Clayton. It was a bad one, I know—”

“The hell it wasn’t my idea,” Regina blurted, putting her fists on her hips as she glared at Elizabeth. There she went again, cursing. She’d been doing a lot of that since Elizabeth came into town. She looked at Mr. Clayton, allowing that passion to bring her courage. “If you’d just give this girl a chance—”

“Never. Did you think tricking me would help your case, Ms. Ashton? Really I can’t say I’m surprised, after the way you hounded me the whole way here.” He threw his napkin on the table, his face still red. “Get. Out. Of Hemlock Veils. Tonight, when I return, if there’s any sign of you here, I’ll take the necessary steps to rid this town of you myself.”

“Mr. Clayton,” Regina reprimanded in a stunned breath. Rather than scare her, at that second he repulsed her. “You have no right—”

The way his eyes shot from Elizabeth’s to her own cut her off short. “It’s my town, Mrs. Washington. I have every right to refuse whomever I want. I will not be lied to, not here. No matter how good the coffee is. Take this as your warning: if you ever attempt anything so scheming again, I will fire you. And I really don’t want to do that.” He paused. “Is that clear?”

“Yes,” was all she could say, with a hint of enmity. She lifted her chin. She and Mr. Clayton had never been enemies before, but it seemed like a good time to start.

Elizabeth’s brow knitted when he looked at her. He shook his head with a disappointment Regina used to see on Nathaniel when he punished their son, many years ago and in a past Regina tried not to dwell on often. “Look what you’ve stirred here, Ms. Ashton.” He appeared offended, like Elizabeth had insulted him in the worst way, which made no sense at all.