Henry the Hurdle lounged in his seat, back resting against the inn’s wall, his hands in his belt, belching softly and contentedly with his eyes half-closed. With the sun warming him, he thought he could be in France, except he preferred the drink in England. Watered wine was a pale substitute for good ale, even if it was weak ale. Margery was a very capable alewife, and her strong ale was powerful enough to put men to sleep when they were unused to it; her weak ale, brewed with less malt, had a pleasing, silky mildness, and Henry had already enjoyed three pints. He disliked the continental habit of adulterating good ale with weeds like hops; it made the drink too bitter, and everyone knew it was bad for the health, making the Flemish in northern France, who drank it in huge quantities, fat and bellicose. Beer was not as wholesome as good English ale.

His sense of well-being was rudely shattered when John dug him in the ribs. “It’s the Keeper, Henry. Henry, wake up! The Keeper and his friend are here, the two who found us last night. They’re back again.”

Risking a quick glance from lowered brows, Henry watched the bailiff and his friend. They paused in the doorway, taking in the scene, three men close behind them, before beginning to stroll in the direction of their table. He stretched and yawned, then forced himself upright. “Let’s see what they want.”

Smiling cheerfully, he was the picture of relaxed honesty, but in his mind he was running through the story of what had happened the night before. Henry knew of the Keeper’s reputation in the area: he was able to divine the truth in the way that people spoke, if you trusted what was said about him in the town. Henry did not believe in such powers, but he was prepared to accept that Baldwin was astute, and Henry did not want the knight guessing what had really happened the previous day, so he fixed his smile as firmly as if it had been nailed in place, and waited.

To Baldwin, from a distance they were like any ordinary pair of men taking their ease in the sun. One dozing, the other resting his elbows on the table and sipping at a large pot of ale. It was as he approached and could see their faces that he felt a pang of disgust. If his first impression of Cole was favorable, his immediate reaction to these two in the daylight was the reverse.

The night before he had thought that one was an ill-favored wretch, and now he could see that his recollection was overly generous. In broad daylight John Smithson was as unpleasing a sight as it was possible to imagine, with sallow features, a narrow, steeply raked forehead, sharp face and light, unsettling eyes which avoided Baldwin’s gaze. As they got closer, Baldwin was treated to a sight of Smithson taking a swallow of his ale. A portion fell from his mouth, and he wiped at it with the back of his hand. The knight was grateful not to have seen him eating.

There was nobody else at their table. Several other tables were filled with men from the band, and Simon wondered why these two sat alone, but the thought was fleeting, and he put it from his mind as he took his rest.

This discussion would take some time, Hugh saw moodily. He stood glumly behind his master as the inevitable questions began, Baldwin staring pensively at Henry.

“Last night we were all tired, and the excitement of the chase dulled our wits. I can hardly recall what you said about this man Cole and how you caught him. Could you run through it again?”

Hugh listened while the man told how he and his friend had noticed Cole in town. Originally they had gone after him to invite him to join them in a drink, but on approaching him, they had become suspicious at his behavior. He walked furtively, like a man who had something to hide, so they decided to follow him. He clearly knew the town, for he ducked into narrow alleys, only rarely passed where he could be seen and avoided places where the other members of Sir Hector’s troop might go. They passed under lines of washing, being spattered by drips, and around filthy dumps, until they saw him drop something. They heard it rattle and spin like a coin, saw it glitter, and realized it must be a plate. With horror, they suddenly understood what must have happened: he’d stolen their master’s silver and run away.

As he bent to pick up the fallen plate, Cole happened to glance behind him and – here Henry gave a chagrined smile as if he was disgraced by his stupidity – caught sight of Henry. If Henry had been less keen to see what it was he had dropped, he implied, Cole might not have spotted him. As it was, he had started to run away. They had called for help, but there didn’t seem to be anyone around, and they had chased after him for miles until catching up with him some way out of the town.

Hugh’s attention began to wander. He had heard it all the night before, and was not interested in the finer details of how the two heroes had managed to bring down their prey. At another table a short way off was space for three men, with a slight squeeze. He knew Edgar was committed to the protection of his master come what may, but there was little need to stand immediately behind Simon and Baldwin; a seat a few yards further off would surely be no difficulty. He indicated such to Roger, who leaned against the tree, bored, then tried to get Edgar’s attention. It was only when Hugh took a step back that Edgar noticed him. Hugh jerked his head to the table silently, and Edgar looked from it to his master, then nodded.

Simon was aware of the departure of the three. He saw them taking their seats nearby, then turned back to Henry.

“I am surprised that no one heard you when you called for help,” Baldwin observed.

“So was I, sir,” Henry spread his hands, palms up, in a show of exasperation. “If someone had helped it would have saved us a long run.”

“Yes. It seems quite clear, though, what happened.” Baldwin was lapsing into the slow way of speaking which some mistook for drowsiness, but which Simon recognized as proof of extreme concentration on details. “You were after him for how long, roughly?”

“I suppose about three hours,” Henry said, shooting a glance at his friend. John shrugged.

“How can I tell? It was afternoon when we first saw him, and dark when you caught up with us.”

“Let us assume it was late afternoon, then. Perhaps you could tell us approximately how long you spent following him and how long chasing him?”

“I’m sorry, sir, but I couldn’t say. No, I’ve got no idea. Anyway, does it matter?”

“Perhaps not, but I was wondering where Cole could have disposed of the silver he stole. And when, of course.”

“When?”

Simon broke in, “Yes, when. When seems to be an interesting problem with every aspect of this matter. When did he get into your captain’s room; when did he take the silver; when did he escape with it; when did he hide it? The only point of any interest apart from that is where he hid it, or with whom.”

“Because, of course, there was more than one man involved,” Baldwin added.

“How can you tell that?” asked Smithson quickly.

Baldwin ignored him. “Sir Hector is a cautious man, isn’t he?”

“Oh, yes. Very. He has to be. In his time he has managed to annoy some powerful men, both here in England and in France. It is only natural that he should be careful.”

“He must be very wary of strangers.”

“Yes.”

“And I suppose he makes sure that nobody he does not know, and know well, can get close to his food or drink.”

Henry leaned back comfortably in his seat. “Yes. Some of his enemies might try to hurt him through poison.”

“And he must be sure, really sure, of only a small number of men.”

“That’s right.”

“Like you, for example.”

“Yes. I’ve been with him for many years.” He smiled.

“Do you remember Cole’s brother?”

Henry frowned. “Cole’s brother?” he asked uncertainly.