St. James Tavern

Creeley came here several times.

Apparently didn't use drugs while here.

Not sure whom he met with, but maybe cops from the nearby 118th Precinct of the NYPD.

Last time he was here-just before his death-he got into an argument with persons unknown.

Checked money from officers at St. James-serial numbers are clean, but found coke and heroin. Stolen from precinct?

Not much drugs missing, only 6 or 7 oz. of pot, 4 of coke.

Unusually few organized crime cases at the 118th Precinct but no evidence of intentional stalling by officers.

Two gangs in the East Village possible but not likely suspects.

Interview with Jordan Kessler, Creeley's partner, and follow-up with wife.

Confirmed no obvious drug use.

Didn't appear to associate with criminals.

Drinking more than usual, taken up gambling; trips to Vegas and Atlantic City. Losses were large, but not significant to Creeley.

Not clear why he was depressed.

Kessler didn't recognize burned records.

Awaiting list of clients.

Kessler doesn't appear to gain by Creeley's death.

Sachs and Pulaski followed by AMG Mercedes.

FRANK SARKOWSKI HOMICIDE

Sarkowski was 57 years old, no police record, murdered on November 4 of this year, survived by wife and two teenage children.

Victim owned building and business in Manhattan. Business was doing maintenance for other companies and utilities.

Art Snyder was case detective.

No suspects.

Murder/robbery?

Business deal went bad?

Killed in Queens-not sure why he was there.

File and evidence missing.

No known connection with Creeley.

No criminal record-Sarkowski or company.

The bungalow was in Long Island City, that portion of Queens just over the East River from Manhattan and Roosevelt Island.

Christmas decorations-plenty of them-were perfectly arranged in the yard, the sidewalk perfectly cleared of ice and snow, the Camry in the driveway perfectly clean, despite the recent snow. Window frames were being scraped for a new coat of paint, and a stack of bricks sat destined for a new path or patio.

This was the house of a man with newly acquired free time.

Amelia Sachs hit the doorbell.

The front door opened a few seconds later and a solid man in his late fifties squinted up at her. He was in a green velour running suit.

"Detective Snyder?" Sachs was careful to use his former title. Being polite gets you further than a gun, her father used to say.

"Yeah, come on in. You're Amelia, right?"

Last name versus first name. You always choose which battles you want to fight. She smiled, shook his hand and followed him inside. Cold streetlight bled inside and the living room was unfriendly and chill. Sachs smelled damp smoke from the fireplace, as well as the scent of cat. She pulled off her jacket and sat on a wheezing sofa. It was clear that the Barcalounger, beside which were three remote controls, was the king's throne.

"The wife's out," he announced. A squint. "You Herman Sachs's girl?"

Girl…

"That's right. Did you work with him?"

"Some, yeah. BK and a couple assignments in Manhattan. Good guy. Heard the retirement party was a blast. Went on all night. You want a soda or water or anything? No booze, sorry." He said this with a certain tone in his voice, which-along with the cluster of veins in his nose-told her that, like a lot of cops of a certain age, he'd had a problem with the bottle. And was now in recovery. Good for him.

"Nothing for me, thanks…just have a few questions. You were case detective on a robbery/homicide just before you retired. Name was Frank Sarkowski."

Eyes sweeping the carpet. "Yeah, remember him. Some businessman. Got shot in a mugging or something."

"I wanted to see the file. But it's gone. The evidence too."

"No file?" Snyder shrugged, a little surprised. Not too much. "Records room at the house…always a mess."

"I need to find out what happened."

"Geez, I don't remember much." Snyder scratched the back of his muscular hand, flaking with eczema. "You know, one of those cases. No leads at all…I mean zip. After a week you kind of forget about 'em. You musta run some of those."

The question was almost a taunt, a comment on the fact that she obviously hadn't been a detective for long and probably hadn't run many of those sorts of cases. Or any other, for that matter.

She didn't respond. "Tell me what you remember."

"Found him in this vacant lot, lying by his car. No money, no wallet. The piece was nearby."

"What was it?"

"A cold Smittie knockoff. Was wiped clean-no prints."

Interesting. Cold meant no serial numbers. The bad guys bought them on the street when they wanted an untraceable weapon. You could never completely obliterate the numbers of a stamped gun-which was a requirement for all U.S. manufacturers-but some foreign weapon companies didn't put serial numbers on their products. They were what professional killers used and often left behind at crime scenes.

"Snitches hear anything afterward?"

Many homicides were solved because the killer made the mistake of bragging about his prowess at a robbery and exaggerating what he'd stolen. Word often got back to snitches, who'd dime the guy out for a favor from the cops.

"Nothing."

"Where was the vacant lot?"

"By the canal. You know those big tanks?"

"The natural gas tanks?"

"Yeah."

"What was he doing there?"

Snyder shrugged. "No idea. He had this maintenance company. I think one of his clients was out there, and he was checking on them or something."

"Crime Scene find anything solid? Trace? Fingerprints? Footprints?"

"Nothing jumped out at us." His rheumy eyes kept examining her. He seemed a little bewildered. He might be thinking, So this is the new generation NYPD. Glad I got out when I did.

"Were you convinced everything was what it seemed to be? A robbery that went bad."

He hesitated. "Pretty convinced."

"But not totally convinced?"

"I guess it coulda been a clip."

"Pro?"

Snyder shrugged. "I mean, there's nobody around. You've gotta walk a half mile just to get to a residential street. It's all factories and things. Kids just don't hang there. There's no reason to. I was thinking the shooter took the wallet and money to make it look like a mugging. And leaving the gun behind-that smelled like a hit to me."

"But no connection to the mob?"

"Not that I found. But one of his employees told me he'd just had some business deal fall through. Lost a lot of money. I followed up but it didn't lead anywhere."

So Sarkowski-maybe Creeley too-might've been working with some OC crew: drugs or money laundering. It went south and they killed him. That would explain the Mercedes tail-some capos or soldiers were checking up on her investigation-and the cops at the 118 were running interference for the crew.

"The name Benjamin Creeley come up in your investigation?"

He shook his head.

"Did you know that the vic-Sarkowski-used to hang at the St. James?"

"The St. James…Wait, that bar in Alphabet City? Around the corner from…" His voice faded.

"That's right. The One One Eight."

Snyder was troubled. "I didn't know that. No."

"Well, he did. Funny that a guy who lived on the West Side and worked in Midtown would hang out in a dive way over there. You know anything about that?"

"Naw. Not a single thing." He looked around the room sullenly. "But if you're asking me if anybody at the One One Eight came to me and said bury the Sarkowski case, they didn't. We ran it by the book and got on to other shit."