Now they were hungry, there was hardly any food left, no coal or even wood, and they were too frightened to go out, but the time was coming when they would have to, or starve inside. Monk fished in his pocket and left two coins on the table, saying nothing, but seeing their eyes go to them.

"Well?" Vida demanded when they were out on the street again, facing into the wind, heads down. There was a thin rime of ice on the stones and the snow was lying over it. It looked eerie in the gloom, reflecting back the distant streetlamps with a pale blur against the black of the roofs and walls and the dense, lightless sky. It was slippery and dangerous underfoot.

Monk shoved his hands deeper into his pockets and hunched his coat around him. His body was rigid with anger, and it was making him even colder.

"Two or three men are beating and raping working women," he answered bitterly. "They're not local men, but they could be from anywhere else. They're not labourers, but they could be clerks, shopkeepers, traders or gentlemen. They could be soldiers on leave or sailors ashore. They didn't even have to be the same men each time, although they probably are.”

"Fat lot o' use that is!" she spat at him. "We bloody know that much!

I in't paying yer ter tell me wot me own sense can see! I thought you were supposed to be the best rozzer in the force! Leastways you always acted like you was!" Her voice was high and sharp with not only disgust, but fear. The emotion had torn through her. She had trusted him, and he had let her down. She had nowhere else to turn.

"Did you expect me to solve it tonight?" he asked sarcastically. "One evening, and I'm supposed to come up with names or proof? You don't want a detective, you want a magician.”

She stopped and faced him. For a moment she was about to come back with something equally vicious. It was instinct to fight back. Then reality asserted itself. Her body sagged. He could only see the outline of it in the dim light and the falling snow. They were twenty yards from the nearest lamp.

"Can yer 'elp or not, Monk? I in't got no timeter play games with yer.”

An old man shuffled past them carrying a sack, muttering to himself.

"I think so," Monk answered her. "They didn't materialise out of the ground. They came here somehow, probably a hansom. They hung around before they attacked these women. They may have had a drink or two.

Somebody saw them. Somebody drove them here, and drove them away again. There were either two or three of them. Men looking for women don't usually go around in twos and threes. Someone will remember.”

"An yer'll make 'em talk," she said with a downwards fall in her voice, as if memory was bitter, and there was pain and regret in it.

How did she know so much about him? Was it all repute, and if so, of what? They were in the borders of his area, when he had been on the force. Or had they known each other well before, better than she had implied? Another case, another time. What was it she knew of him, and he did not know of himself? She knew he was clever, and ruthless…

and she did not like him, but she respected his ability. In a perverse way she trusted him. And she believed he could work in Seven Dials.

Far more than if she had been some decent, wealthy woman, he wanted to succeed for her. It was mainly because of the rage in him against the brutality of these men, the injustice of it all, their lives, and the lives of these women; but it was also pride. He would show her he was still the man he had been in the past. He had lost none of his skills… only memory! Everything else was the same, even better! Runcorn might not know that…

The thought of Runcorn brought him up sharply. Runcorn had been his superior, but never felt it. He was always aware of Monk treading on his heels, Monk being better dressed, quick witted, sharper tongued, Monk always waiting to catch him out!

Was that memory speaking to him, or only what he had deduced from Runcorn's attitude after the accident?

This was Runcorn's area. When he had the evidence it would be Runcorn he would have to take it to.

"Yes… he said aloud. "It might be hard to find where they come from… but easier to find where they went. They'd be dirty, after rolling on the cobbles with the women, fighting. One or two of them might have been marked. Those women fought… enough at least to scratch or bite." His mind was picturing shadowy figures only, but some things he knew. "They'd be elated, touched with both victory and fear. They'd done a monstrous thing. Some echo of that would be there in their manner. Some cabby, somewhere, will have noticed. He would know where he took them, because it would be out of the area.”

"Said you was a clever sod," she let out her breath in a sigh of relief. "Nah there's one more fer yer ter see. Dot Mac Rae She's married legal, but 'er us band useless. Consumptive, poor devil. Can't do nothin'. Coughin' 'is lungs up. She gotta work, an' shirt stitchin' don't do it.”

Monk did not argue, nor did he need it explaining to him. Somewhere in his memory was burned such knowledge. He walked beside her in the thickening snow. Other people were hurrying by, heads down, occasionally calling out a greeting or even a joke. Two men staggered out of a public house, supporting each other as far as the gutter, then collapsed, cursing, but without anger. A beggar wrapped his coat tighter around himself and settled down in a doorway. Within moments another joined him. Together they would be warmer than separately.

Dot Mac Rae told them essentially what they had already heard. She was older than the others, maybe forty, but still handsome. Her face had character and there was courage in her eyes. There was also a helpless anger. She was trapped and she knew it. She did not expect either help or pity. She told Monk quite simply what had happened some two and a half weeks ago when she had been attacked by two men approaching her from opposite sides of a courtyard. Yes, she had been quite certain it had been only two men. One of them had held her down while the other had raped her, then when she had fought back, they had both beaten and kicked her, leaving her almost senseless on the ground.

She had been found and helped home by Percy, a beggar who frequently slept in a doorway in the area. He had seen there was something badly wrong, and done all he could to assist her. He had wanted to report it to someone, but who was there? Who cared about a woman who sold her body being beaten a little, or taken by force?

Vida did not comment, but again her feeling was evident in her face.

Monk asked questions about time and place, anything Dot could remember which would differentiate these men from any others.

She had not seen them clearly, they had been no more than shapes, weight, pain in the darkness. She had been aware of an overwhelming sense of rage in them, and then afterwards excitement, even elation.

Monk walked away through the snow so blind with anger he was almost oblivious of being cold. He had left Vida Hopgood at the corner of her street, and then turned to leave Seven Dials and head back towards the open thoroughfares, the lights and the traffic of the main areas of the city. Later he would find a hansom and ride the rest of the way to his rooms in Grafton Street. Now he needed to think, and to feel the quick exercise of muscles, pour his energy into movement, and smart under the sting of ice on his face.

This helpless rage at injustice was familiar. It was an old pain, dating far back before the accident, into the times he only caught glimpses of when some emotion, or some half-caught sight or smell, carried him back. He knew the real source of it. The man who had been his guide and mentor when he had newly come south from Northumberland, bound to make his fortune in London, the man who had taken him in, taught him so much not only about merchant banking and the uses of money, but about cultured life, about society and how to be a gentleman, he had been ruined by injustice. Monk had done everything he could to help him, and it had not been enough. He had suffered that same feeling of frustration then, of pacing the streets racking his brain for ideas, of believing the answer was beyond his reach, but only just.